Volunteers Are Mission-Critical — So Why Are We Undervaluing Their Experience?
Volunteers are the driving force behind many of the world’s most impactful charities and non-profit organisations. They contribute time, talent, and heart to causes they believe in — helping organisations scale their reach, serve communities in need, and advance their missions in meaningful ways.
Yet despite their central importance, volunteer programs often lack the strategic investment they deserve. Many non-profits continue to rely on generic HR systems or manual tools like spreadsheets to manage their volunteer workforce — tools that were never designed with volunteer engagement in mind.
As a result, volunteers are often met with disjointed, time-consuming processes that don’t reflect their motivations or expectations. And organisations are left struggling with low retention, poor engagement, and inefficient operations.
This isn’t just an operational issue — it’s a missed opportunity.
That’s why we’ve released a powerful new white paper that explores why modern volunteer programs need more than makeshift systems — they need dedicated Volunteer Management Software (VMS). More than a tool, VMS is a strategic investment in the future of volunteering.
_____________________________________________________________________________________
The Landscape Has Changed — And So Have Volunteers
Charities and non-profits are operating in an increasingly challenging environment. Rising demand for services, tightening budgets, and evolving societal expectations are reshaping the sector. At the same time, the volunteer landscape is also changing. Volunteers today:
- Expect digital-first, self-service experiences
- Want more flexibility and control over when and how they contribute
- Value clear communication, meaningful recognition, and purpose-driven engagement
Traditional HR systems and manual methods simply weren’t built to meet these needs. They may offer a short-term, cost-effective workaround — but they come at a high long-term price: disengagement, inefficiencies, and missed opportunities for growth.
In fact, over 60% of organisations in Australia and New Zealand report difficulties with volunteer recruitment and retention based on data from the Australian Bureau of Statistics and Stats NZ . These challenges are symptomatic of a deeper issue: outdated tools that fail to prioritise the volunteer experience.
What’s Holding Volunteer Programs Back?
In the white paper, we explore the core limitations of relying on HR systems or spreadsheets to manage volunteers. These include:
1. Rigid Functionality
HR systems are designed for employees with fixed schedules and predictable workflows. Volunteers, on the other hand, operate on flexible, sometimes ad hoc schedules — from one-off events to ongoing commitments. These tools can’t easily adapt to the dynamic nature of volunteer engagement.
2. Limited Scalability
Volunteer programs often involve hundreds or even thousands of individuals. Managing such a diverse and transient group requires systems that can scale easily and update in real-time — something most HR platforms aren’t equipped to do.
3. Lack of Engagement Tools
Volunteers aren’t employees — they’re mission-driven individuals who give their time freely. Keeping them motivated requires more than basic scheduling; it requires features like gamification, recognition, personalisation, and two-way communication — features rarely found in traditional systems.
4. Hidden Costs
What seems like a cost-effective solution often leads to wasted time and resources. Manual onboarding, scheduling, compliance tracking, and communication add up quickly, taking staff away from strategic work and diminishing program efficiency.
_____________________________________________________________________________________
The Case for VMS: Purpose-Built for Impact
So, what’s the alternative? That’s where Volunteer Management Software (VMS) comes in.
VMS platforms are designed specifically for the complexities and opportunities of managing volunteers. They streamline and automate key processes — from recruitment and onboarding to scheduling, engagement, and reporting — while creating a positive and empowering experience for volunteers.
Here are just a few benefits covered in the white paper:
- Streamlined scheduling that matches volunteer availability to program needs
- Self-service portals that let volunteers sign up for shifts, manage their preferences, and track their contributions
- Automated onboarding for faster and more efficient recruitment
- Communication tools for instant updates and reminders
- Recognition features like certificates, milestones, and gamification to boost retention
- Data and analytics to report on impact, inform strategy, and satisfy funders
Real-World Results: Lifeline Australia's Transformation
The white paper also features a powerful case study on Lifeline Australia, a national charity that supports over a million Australians each year through crisis and suicide prevention services.
Before switching to Rosterfy, Lifeline was managing its volunteer recruitment through spreadsheets — a manual, time-consuming process that limited their ability to scale. After implementing Rosterfy’s VMS, Lifeline:
- Reduced volunteer application admin by 50%
- Increased processing speed from 3–5 applications per hour to 10–12
- Streamlined complex screening workflows with custom automations
- Improved volunteer experience and scalability for future growth
For Lifeline, the move to a purpose-built system wasn’t just a tech upgrade — it was a transformational shift that helped them better serve both their volunteers and the community.
_____________________________________________________________________________________
Digital Transformation Is No Longer Optional
Based on data from Volunteering New Zealand and the Australian Bureau of Statistics, more than 3.6 million people volunteer every year across Australia and New Zealand, contributing billions of dollars in value to the economy. In this landscape, the need for modernisation is clear.
Digital transformation in volunteer management is no longer a luxury — it’s a necessity.
Organisations that fail to evolve risk falling behind. Those that embrace VMS can drive greater efficiency, empower their teams, and most importantly, provide volunteers with the meaningful, frictionless experience they deserve.
Whether you're managing a small group of volunteers or running national programs, the insights in this white paper will help you:
- Identify inefficiencies in your current system
- Build a compelling business case for VMS investment
- Choose the right platform for your needs
- Unlock the full potential of your volunteer program
Conclusion: It’s Time to Invest in What Really Matters
The success of any volunteer organisation comes down to the strength of its people — and that includes volunteers. Prioritising the volunteer experience through dedicated tools like Rosterfy isn’t just about improving efficiency. It’s about investing in your mission and building a foundation for long-term impact.
As Katie Bradshaw from NCVO puts it:
“Financial investment in volunteering is not just a cost — it’s an investment in the future.”
Download the white paper today to learn how to modernise your volunteer management strategy and deliver the impact your community deserves.
Book a demo to discover how Rosterfy can take your volunteer programme to the next level.