Volunteer Retention 101: Creating a Culture They Can't Resist

A positive volunteer experience isn’t just about ensuring the present, but securing a brighter future for your organization and the people you serve.

Volunteers are the backbone of your organization, providing essential support, dedication, and passion for your cause. However, you’ve likely felt the strain of volunteer turnover, especially in the wake of the COVID-19 pandemic. High volunteer turnover could profoundly affect your ability to meet your goals and maintain momentum.

Understanding Volunteer Turnover

Just like in the corporate world, high turnover among volunteers can be costly and disruptive. Yet, unlike employees, volunteers offer their time and skills without financial compensation, making their continued commitment even more reliant on a positive experience.

The Impact of Volunteer Experience on Turnover

The volunteer experience directly correlates with turnover rates. When volunteers feel valued, appreciated, and engaged, they are more likely to continue their service. Conversely, a negative or unfulfilling experience can prompt volunteers to leave, impacting your organization’s ability to maintain your mission.
Happy cheerful young asian male in glasses smiling and using laptop in cafe

Factors Influencing Your Volunteer Retention

Volunteer engagement is the cornerstone of retention; it's the driving force behind a volunteer's commitment and dedication to your organization. Here's a deeper look at how engagement plays a pivotal role in retaining volunteers.

Connection to the Cause

Engaged volunteers deeply resonate with the mission and goals of your organization. When they feel a personal connection to your cause, they are more likely to remain committed over the long term. Organizations that effectively communicate their purpose and impact tend to attract and retain volunteers who share their passion.

Meaningful Roles and Responsibilities

Assigning your volunteers tasks that align with their skills, interests, and motivations is crucial. Engaged volunteers find fulfillment in their roles; they feel their contributions matter and make a difference. When their work is meaningful, they are more likely to stay committed.

Opportunities for Growth

Engaged volunteers are eager to learn and grow within your organization. Providing avenues for skill development, advancement, and leadership roles not only enriches their experience but also fosters a sense of belonging and investment in your organization’s success.

Open Communication and Feedback

A culture of open communication where volunteers feel heard and valued is vital. Engaged volunteers appreciate being part of discussions, having their opinions considered, and seeing their feedback actively implemented. This inclusivity fosters a sense of ownership and investment in your organization's future.

Recognition and Appreciation

Recognizing volunteers for their efforts and achievements is key. Public acknowledgment, gratitude through awards or certificates, or even a simple thank-you note goes a long way. Feeling appreciated reinforces a volunteer's commitment and encourages continued participation.

Sense of Community and Belonging

Building a strong sense of community among volunteers creates a support network. Engaged volunteers feel connected to their peers, sharing experiences, collaborating, and supporting each other. This camaraderie strengthens their bond with your organization.

Flexibility and Respect for Time

Acknowledging and respecting volunteers' time by offering flexible schedules and accommodating their commitments outside of volunteering demonstrates appreciation. Engaged volunteers are more likely to stay when they feel their time is valued.

Regular and Engaging Activities

Keeping volunteers engaged between major projects or events is vital. Regular engagement through smaller tasks, social events, or educational sessions maintains their interest and involvement, preventing burnout or disengagement.
Volunteer engagement is a continuous cycle of connection, contribution, and appreciation. Organizations that prioritize and cultivate an environment where volunteers feel valued, respected, and engaged are more likely to retain dedicated individuals committed to their cause.
Portrait of a smiling cute woman making selfie photo on smartphone isolated on a white background

Strategies to Keep Your Volunteers Coming Back

Personalized Onboarding

Personalized onboarding starts by understanding what each volunteer brings to the table. By assessing their skills, interests, and motivations, your organization can match volunteers to roles that align with their strengths and passions. This tailored approach ensures volunteers feel valued from the beginning.
Clear communication about roles, responsibilities, and expectations is crucial. Volunteers who have a precise understanding of what is expected from them are more likely to feel confident and engaged in their roles.
Personalized onboarding isn't just about tasks; it's about building relationships. Taking the time to get to know your volunteers on an individual level, understanding their aspirations and concerns, helps establish a rapport that encourages long-term commitment.
Personalized onboarding sets the stage for a positive volunteer experience. It demonstrates your organization's commitment to understanding and leveraging each volunteer's unique skills and interests, fostering a sense of belonging and value that encourages long-term engagement.

Regular Check-ins

Regular check-ins with volunteers are a fundamental aspect of maintaining engagement and fostering a supportive environment. These scheduled meetings or touchpoints go beyond mere status updates; they serve as opportunities to connect, support, and address any concerns or feedback.
Through these check-ins, you’ll gain insights into your volunteers' experiences, challenges, and aspirations. Understanding their needs enables better support and tailored solutions, enhancing their overall experience.
Tracking volunteers' progress toward their goals or milestones happens during these check-ins. It's an opportunity to celebrate achievements and set new objectives, keeping volunteers motivated and engaged. Check-ins promote a culture of transparency and open communication. Volunteers feel more comfortable expressing concerns or ideas, fostering a collaborative environment.
By scheduling regular check-ins, you‘ll demonstrate your commitment to your volunteers' success and well-being. This in turn reinforces your volunteers' dedication to your cause and organization.

Skill Development Opportunities

Skill development initiatives keep volunteers engaged and motivated. Learning new skills or refining existing ones adds value to their experience, making their contributions more meaningful. As volunteer roles evolve within an organization, skill development ensures volunteers are equipped to handle new challenges and responsibilities. When volunteers feel competent and capable, they perform better, contributing more efficiently to your organization's goals.
Learning new skills also broadens volunteers' horizons. It exposes them to different areas of interest or expertise they might not have explored otherwise, encouraging diverse participation within the organization. Organizations that invest in skill development tend to retain volunteers for longer periods. Additionally, the prospect of acquiring new skills can attract new volunteers looking for growth opportunities.
Providing skill development opportunities is a strategic investment in your volunteers. It not only enhances their current contributions but also fosters their personal and professional growth, leading to a more fulfilling volunteer experience and increased retention rates.

Flexible Scheduling

Your volunteers have other obligations like work, education, and family responsibilities. Offering flexibility in scheduling demonstrates respect for their time and commitments outside of volunteering. Your volunteers are more likely to stay committed when they feel their scheduling needs are understood and accommodated.
Remember that life circumstances can change, affecting your volunteers' availability. Flexible scheduling allows for adjustments without causing your volunteers to disengage due to schedule conflicts.
Flexible scheduling also makes volunteering accessible to a wider range of individuals. It allows people with diverse schedules or part-time availability to participate, fostering a more inclusive volunteer community.
Providing flexible scheduling options is essential for your organization to retain volunteers. It promotes a supportive environment that respects volunteers' time and commitments, leading to higher engagement, satisfaction, and long-term commitment to your organization's mission.

Celebrating Milestones

Milestone celebrations acknowledge the time, effort, and commitment volunteers have dedicated to your organization. It's a great way to express gratitude for their contributions. It validates their efforts and encourages them to continue their commitment. When volunteers feel appreciated, they are more likely to stay engaged.
Milestone celebrations foster a sense of belonging among your volunteers. They bring them together, creating a supportive community where achievements are shared and celebrated. Publicly celebrating milestones can also inspire other volunteers to reach similar achievements. It sets positive examples and encourages a culture of excellence and dedication.
Milestone celebrations serve as milestones themselves, marking progress and encouraging volunteers to set new goals or benchmarks for their involvement. Celebrating milestones not only boosts morale and motivation but also fosters a sense of belonging and appreciation, leading to increased volunteer retention and a stronger, more dedicated volunteer base.

Feedback Mechanisms

Feedback mechanisms create a channel for volunteers to express their opinions, ideas, and concerns. This demonstrates that your organization values your volunteers' opinions and experiences. When volunteers feel their input matters, they are more likely to stay engaged and committed.
Timely feedback allows your organization to address concerns or issues promptly. This proactive approach prevents problems from escalating and helps maintain a positive volunteer experience. Feedback mechanisms contribute to a culture of continuous improvement within your organization.
A robust feedback mechanism builds trust between volunteers and your organization. Volunteers feel more connected when they see their feedback being taken seriously, leading to stronger relationships. Giving your volunteers a voice in shaping their experience and your organization's direction leads to increased ownership and commitment.
Feedback mechanisms ensure that your organization retains valuable insights from volunteers, even if they decide to move on. This feedback can be instrumental in improving volunteer experiences for current and future volunteers.


The success of your organization heavily relies on the dedication and continuity of your volunteer base. Understanding the pivotal role of volunteer experience in determining turnover rates is crucial. By prioritizing engagement, recognition, support, and communication, you can create an environment where volunteers feel valued, leading to increased retention rates and sustained impact.
A positive volunteer experience isn’t just about ensuring the present, but securing a brighter future for your organization and the people you serve.

About Rosterfy

Rosterfy is used by nonprofits, charities, sporting federations, and more to better manage their volunteer programs by improving how they can recruit, screen, train, and retain volunteers.
Our market leading technology helps you create an engaging experience throughout the whole lifecycle of your volunteer journey.

Similar posts

Join our Newsletter Mailing List

Be the first to know about new Volunteer Management insights, news and feature updates to Rosterfy.